In Inuktitut, the word used for news is
pivalliajut. Its literal translation is
"things that are gradually developing." For Jim Bell, editor of
the weekly Nunavut newspaper, Nunatsiaq
News, things always seem to be developing too
gradually. This early November morning, for instance, he is fed
up with the persistence of fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) in the
territory. In a story meeting with his staff, he is twitching
with frustration about a Government of Nunavut (GN) "pilot
project" to teach women about the dangers of drinking while
pregnant. At 52, Bell is robust and fit, with silvering hair that
waves dashingly at his brow, and a full beard that comes and goes
according to the dictates of his vanity. His face reaches its
height of handsomeness at moments like this one, consumed with
confusion and contempt, as he reflects that FAS has been "news"
for more than 10 years. "Maybe," he says, "people are doing it
even though they know it will harm their
babies."
Bell has even less time for the
government's concern that the education campaign might be
experienced as "scolding" by mothers who already have children
with FAS.
"This is not about the moms, it's
about the kids. Why does it matter if a mother feels bad or not?
She already knows she's damaged her child," says Bell. He then
focuses on the government. "What kind of moral thinking do these
people do? It's ridiculous."
"I don't know,"
ventures Sara Minogue, the assistant editor. "I guess they're
just sensitive people, unlike others."
"They're
idiots," Bell retorts.
Few
Nunatsiaq readers would be surprised by this
outburst. It echoes the indignation often typical of Bell's
written voice, which has made him a household name in Nunavut. At
times teetering between outrage and outrageousness, Bell's weekly
editorial keeps a relentless watch on the foibles of Nunavut's
leaders and is the source of both dread and delight across the
territory. Kenn Harper, a prominent Iqaluit entrepreneur and
author who has lived in the North for almost 40 years, calls Bell
"the conscience of Nunavut." Jack Hicks, another well-known
personality in Iqaluit who worked as director of evaluation and
statistics at the GN, says Bell is one of the few voices raising
debate in Nunavut. And Hunter Tootoo, one of the younger and more
confrontational members of legislative assembly in the GN, says
he has heard people on the street say, "Jim Bell's running the
government."
Some
Nunavummiut say Bell walks around with a
dark cloud over his head and sees "the cup" of the new territory
as not half but almost completely empty. He does tend to dwell,
at times rather gloomily, on the hurts in Nunavut. But the truth
is, there are many hurts. Nunavut has fallen far short of the
many hopes pinned on its creation, with 27 per cent of all its
deaths between 1999 and 2003 attributable to suicide; a higher
rate of violent crime than anywhere else in Canada; and more
students dropping out of high school than graduating.
Nunatsiaq News reports on these problems -
sometimes to the point that there appears to be little other
news. While some readers find the paper's coverage too negative,
many others are grateful that it brings the real stories of
Nunavut out into the open. Such a job might call for a person
with a bit of a dark cloud over his head - a person who, like
Bell, thinks "we are ennobled as much by our defeats as by our
victories."
Nunatsiaq News
began as an nonprofit paper called Inukshuk
in 1973, when Iqaluit was still called Frobisher Bay, and its
mission was to help foster communication among Inuit adjusting to
life in the settlements. In 1978, editor Monica Connolly, an
Oshawa resident, bought the paper with a group of other Iqaluit
residents and renamed it Nunatsiaq, meaning
"unspoiled" or "beautiful land." Since its inception,
Nunatsiaq News has always run stories in
both English and Inuktitut, and to this day maintains the
tradition of publishing as many letters to the editor as
possible, often unrelated to the paper's content, including
personal notices of thanks and gripes about community
issues.
In 1985, Connolly sold
Nunatsiaq News to Nortext Publishing Corp.,
the Ottawa-based, family-run publishing company that continues to
own and operate the paper. Over the next seven years,
Nunatsiaq went through a number of
noteworthy changes. It introduced an expensive typesetting system
with an Inuktitut font (previously, Inuktitut copy was
handwritten), experienced a dramatic rise in circulation (from
1,500 to 7,000) that saw the paper reach far-flung communities
across the Northwest Territories, and endured significant staff
turnover, including the firing and rehiring of
Bell.
In 1993, Nunatsiaq
News reached a major turning point in its development.
At that time, Nunavut was well on its way to becoming a
self-determining territory. Its Inuit had signed the Nunavut Land
Claims Agreement with Ottawa, which would result in the division
of the region from the Northwest Territories on April 1, 1999.
Ottawa appointed members to the Nunavut Implementation
Commission, whose role was to advise on how the new territory's
government should be structured. And the Inuit formed Nunavut
Tunngavik Inc., a body whose responsibilities include
distributing the financial compensation provided by Ottawa in
exchange for less-defined rights.
The infusion
of so much political power into Nunavut coincided with the
arrival of Todd Phillips and Lisa Gregoire, both graduates of the
journalism program at the University of Western Ontario, at
Nunatsiaq News. Rather than act as
cheerleaders for the new territory, Phillips and Gregoire wanted
to report the real challenges facing Nunavut at this critical
point in its evolution. Bell, who was then the consulting editor,
was more than happy to show them the
way.
Fortunately, their publishers backed them.
Early in its ownership of Nunatsiaq News,
Nortext opted to keep editorial decisions independent from the
wishes of advertisers, most of whom were part of the Government
of the Northwest Territories, which had a history of threatening
to pull its business when the paper criticized them. And they
were not the only ones uncomfortable with
Nunatsiaq's approach. Phillips remembers
people in the community phoning him at home to complain that
coverage was not relevant to Inuit, or that it was too
depressing. "They would say, 'Your paper's just politics,
politics, and sexual assault,'" recalls Phillips. "The average
citizen would grow weary of that."
The
newsroom, on the other hand, had never been livelier. Gregoire
(who went on to work at the Edmonton Journal
and is currently freelancing) and Phillips (a senior editor at
CLB Media, publisher of several trade magazines) both say working
at Nunatsiaq was one of their best
experiences in journalism, and they both describe Bell as a
mentor. "Jim's overriding motive was to be a mirror for what was
going on in Nunavut at the time," reflects Gregoire. "He was so
committed, for whatever reason, to making sure that his readers
were informed in such a way that they were able to make
appropriate decisions about their lives."
The
Todd-and-Lisa years were brief (Gregoire left in 1995, and
Phillips in 1997) but potent, and the mission of that masthead -
accountability - lives on. Bell resumed the post of editor with
Phillips's departure, and continues to hold up the paper's
reputation for hard-hitting, reliable coverage. A recent example
was a front-page story in November 2004 that suggested the GN
fired a qualified and competent South Asian employee, Harbir
Boparai, from the Department of Economic Development located in
the community of Panniqtuuq (also known as Pangnirtung), due to
rumours of nepotism that were false and possibly fuelled by
racism. Boparai approached Nunatsiaq with
his belief that because he had been staying with another South
Asian man, people in the community assumed the two were related
and that Boparai's host "conspired" to get him a job with the GN.
Nunatsiaq broke the story, complete with an
email excerpt from a GN employee suggesting Boparai's complaint
was valid, and made the government squirm. A month earlier,
Nunatsiaq had covered the less juicy story
of an application by the Nunavut Power Corporation to raise
energy rates, and Bell blasted both the GN and the Iqaluit town
council for "willful stupidity," saying they are apparently
oblivious to the catastrophic impact the increased rates could
have on the territory's economy, and specifically the toll on
"ordinary people." It seems Bell was among a select few who read
the application, and one of the only ones who read between its
lines.
Jim Bell learned to drive in the summer
of 2004. As of November, he still doesn't have a full licence,
but a permit that allows him to operate a vehicle only if
accompanied by a licenced driver. He seems quite comfortable at
the wheel and can recite the rules of the road chapter and verse.
But when he accidentally put the car in park instead of drive,
his reflex was to quickly mutter to himself, "That was
stupid."
Bell expects a lot of himself, but in
his early years, he had no real goals. He never dreamed of being
a journalist. When he finished high school in Oshawa, he worked,
travelled, started and dropped out of the University of Toronto
("I just got very impatient"), and wound up working for Operation
Dismantle, a nuclear disarmament lobby group. He had pacifism in
his blood; his mother's brother had been a conscientious objector
in Bell's native Scotland during the Second World War, and her
family opened its home to men who refused to fight. His father,
on the other hand, was a soldier who fought in that war, and
while he politically supported the war, his near-death
experiences with dysentery and malaria inspired some ambivalence.
"He came back divided in himself about whether what he had done
was worth it or not," says Bell.
By the time he
left Operation Dismantle in the spring of 1979, Bell says he
thought the organization was "a crock." He also had a $5,000 debt
with the Household Financial Corp., which charged 26 per cent
interest, and he was looking to pay back the money as quickly as
possible. He got a job bartending at the Frobisher Inn, known in
those days as "the Zoo," and moved north just in time for
Christmas of 1979. He hated the job and hated seeing people at
their worst. The bar was losing money and three months after he
started, his boss let him go, telling him he was too nice a guy
to be working there.
Bell noticed there was a
newspaper in town. He figured he was "fairly literate" and could
perhaps get a job as a reporter, in spite of having no training
in journalism. Connolly first hired him not as a writer but as an
advertising salesperson - a job Bell guesses she was having more
trouble filling. He quickly got hooked on
Nunatsiaq. When Connolly, burnt out from
working too hard, started spending weeks and even months away
from the newsroom, Bell picked up the slack, doing stories,
layout, sales, circulation - whatever it took to get the paper
out. Though it would still be a number of years before he took
his own talent seriously, he'd found his
calling.
Bell identifies with the saying that
the three pillars of Scottish culture are drinking, smoking, and
swearing. The swearing - at a principal - got him suspended from
high school for half a year, and he spent most of Grade 11 in the
Oshawa Public Library, where he passed his days studying the
development of political theory and listening to John Coltrane's
A Love Supreme. The smoking started when he
was a teenager. The drinking was a part of Bell's early days in
Iqaluit, when he describes having a binging habit, saying he used
alcohol to help him talk to people. He started cutting down in
the late 1980s and gave it up almost altogether in the early
1990s. He no longer wanted to be part of a scene in which alcohol
ruins lives. He also decided it was time to protect the most
important tool of his trade - his
mind.
Physically, Bell is a most careful
person. He walks as though balancing a book on his head, and
dresses in trousers and a collared shirt in a newsroom where most
show up in jeans. He is probably the only person in Iqaluit who
buckles his seat belt. Aside from the odd verbal eruption, in
person Bell is formal and polite, pleasant and professional, at
times a bit shy and awkward. He refuses to submit to social
niceties, bluntly saying his parents are "dead" and telling his
partner "I love you" over the phone in front of a stranger. At
times, this style has made it challenging for Bell to offer
feedback to staff, especially when it is negative. "One thing I
find really hard to talk about is when someone has written a pile
of crap," he says. "I'm not very good at being
diplomatic."
This got Bell into trouble with
Nortext in 1987, about two years after it bought the paper and
hired Bell to be editor. The company poured tens of thousands of
dollars into upgrading Nunatsiaq, but Bell
found himself without the staff or technical support he needed to
cover important stories such as local criminal trials. He grew
angry with Michael Roberts, then publisher, who was living in
Ottawa. In November, a group of schoolchildren visited the
newsroom to ask why there were no games or puzzles in the paper,
and Bell lost it. He penned an editorial in the voice of a child,
bitterly accusing a "man in Ottawa" of not giving the paper
enough money to do its work. By the next edition of
Nunatsiaq News, Bell had been replaced as
editor.
Today, Bell is embarrassed about the
incident. "I was 35 years old," he says, looking sad. "I should
have known better." Even now, his one fear, he says, is of being
too sure of himself, and sees his attack on Nortext as a "classic
example" of this. He admits: "I usually get into trouble when I
become overconfident about an editorial position and don't ask
enough questions."
By the time he left
Nunatsiaq at the end of 1987, Bell had a
strong reputation in the North and he quickly snagged a job as a
part-time teacher in the journalism program at Nunavut Arctic
College. The program lasted only two years, but Bell was not long
unemployed because in 1990, Nortext came calling again. It was
launching a hard-hitting magazine about the North, and wanted
Bell to be involved. "He was the obvious choice to lead that
project," recalls Steven Roberts, current publisher of
Nunatsiaq, and younger brother of Michael,
who was publisher of the magazine. He and Michael harboured no
hard feelings. Bell started as a feature writer, and his story
about the housing crisis in Iqaluit appeared on the cover of the
premiere issue of Arctic Circle. He
eventually became associate editor of the magazine, which
published until 1994. Also in 1990, Nortext brought him back to
Nunatsiaq News, primarily to mentor the
paper's relatively green staff. This often meant writing the
editorial, because younger editors did not always want to "stick
their necks out," as Bell puts it. Greg Coleman, managing editor
at the paper from 1992 to 1993, says: "We used to joke about my
late Thursday walk down to Jim's office to tell him that I just
wasn't comfortable editorializing on anything that week. I can't
exactly say that his eyes didn't light up a little
bit."
Bell claims he gets no more satisfaction
from writing editorials than a good news story, but Minogue has
seen him chuckle to himself in the midst of a rant. How could he
not, when rechristening the government "the Regurgitative
Assembly of Nunavut," or comparing the November Throne Speech to
"recycled puppy food"? Bell is clear about the importance of
being interesting. "I'm not going to work as hard as I do and not
have any readers," he says. At the same time, he is frustrated
that people only seem to notice his "nail to the wall"
editorials. He says he often tries to use editorials to educate
readers about basic political issues, and makes an effort to be
hopeful whenever possible. But his writing voice is strongest and
most authentic when he is frustrated, like the time in 1997 when
he addressed a group of "esteemed citizens" in "insulated
bunkers" who were protesting cuts to the Iqaluit library. "Come
on people," he wrote. "Get your priorities straightened out
before you cause any more embarrassment for those in the
community who do care about the life and death issues many people
are facing here."
In Inuktitut, a person may
only make definite statements about events he or she has actually
witnessed - perhaps a reflection of the tenuousness of life on
frozen land. Jim Bell knows the history of the Inuit. He
understands both the havoc precipitous social change has wreaked
in Nunavut, as well the crushing disappointment the realities of
division have brought. But the inevitable cultural divide between
Inuit and qallunaat (white people), together
with Bell's impatient nature, can sometimes make for an
unsettling gap between Nunatsiaq and its
readers. Paul Quassa, who was a chief negotiator of the Nunavut
Land Claims Agreement, sees the paper as a key player in the
development of literacy in Nunavut, but also says its
journalistic values, such as "digging" for stories or exposing
politicians' transgressions, are foreign to Inuit, who tend to
avoid conflict because their dependence on one another was
critical to surviving on the land. "Media should be more aware of
how Inuit react," says Quassa. "We're still especially leery of
news about people not agreeing with each other." (Quassa is not
an unbiased source; his past problems with alcohol and
questionable use of public money have been the subject of both
news stories and editorials in Nunatsiaq
News.)
Jack Anawak is another
prominent Inuit leader, who, unlike Quassa, has stayed clear of
personal controversy. For this, as well as for his continued
connection to the land, Anawak commands the respect of many
Nunavummiut, including Bell. In February
2003, while serving as minister of culture, language, elders, and
youth, Anawak, on behalf of his constituents, publicly disagreed
with the premier on the relocation of the government's Petroleum
Products Division from Rankin Inlet to Baker Lake. Bell said
Anawak should resign from cabinet for having breached "a cardinal
principle of parliamentary government" - cabinet solidarity.
Anawak is highly professional and articulate, but when asked
about Bell's argument, he momentarily loses his composure. "See,
that's where you start thinking more of politics than the right
thing," he says. "Who the hell is Jim Bell to try to judge what
the cabinet of Nunavut should do? He always knew we were going to
do things differently." Anawak was stripped of his portfolio by
the premier and eventually dismissed from cabinet by the
legislative assembly, but he is confident he might have been
elected premier had he chosen to run for the GN again (instead he
accepted a federal appointment as ambassador for circumpolar
affairs). In a March 2003 editorial, Bell similarly said that
Anawak's removal from cabinet had given him more political clout.
"In Nunavut politics, it's emotion that usually matters, and
Anawak's appeal is aimed at all those who feel that, so far,
Nunavut has not lived up to its promise. Right now, that likely
includes the vast majority of
Nunavummiut."
Jimi Onalik,
a 30-year-old Iqaluit businessman and former GN employee,
believes this disillusionment is contributing to the growing
popularity of the evangelical Christian movement in the North.
James Arreak, a pastor with the Iqaluit Christian Fellowship,
estimates that more than 1,000 people attended the 20th Arctic
Bible Conference in Iqaluit in April 2004. Arreak reads
Nunatsiaq News, but questions its
sensitivity to Inuit values. "People felt deserted by the
newspaper," he says, referring to the coverage of the Christian
campaign against the inclusion of sexual orientation in a human
rights bill the GN debated in 2003. Earlier that year, Bell made
a respectful and persuasive case for gay rights. But in November,
when the act passed, Bell was less tactful, perhaps out of anger
at religious politicians who threw their power into an effort
that almost prevented Nunavut from having a human rights act. He
wrote: "There is only one reason why any person would oppose a
law that makes it illegal to discriminate against gays and
lesbians. And that reason is simple: they want the freedom to
continue practising such discrimination." Bell gloated as he
observed that the ultimate passing of the legislation meant "the
forces of hatred, fear, and superstition" had been defeated, and
concluded with a sarcastic "praise the
law."
Bell understands his comments may have
alienated some religious readers, but does not realize just how
bold others found them. The fact that a member of the business
community would be loath to openly criticize the church for fear
of losing customers is something of a revelation to Bell. "Oh
really," he says. "I didn't know that, actually I didn't know
that people felt that way." It is not clear which surprises him
more - the information or the fact that it is news to
him.
Patricia D'Souza, who was managing editor
at Nunatsiaq between 2001 and 2004, wonders
whether the paper's hard-line approach to the church's anti-gay
position made believers distrustful of the paper, ultimately
costing Nunatsiaq access to sources in the church. "Maybe if we'd
taken a softer tack we could have gotten in more, and gotten
better stories," she says. "I don't think I ever understood how
the church became as influential as it
is."
Wednesday is production day in the
Nunatsiaq newsroom, and at 5 P.M., Bell is
finishing his editorial. He types almost without pause, his jaw
working hard on the gum that helps with the cigarettes, which he
gave up in the spring of 2003. He is writing about Harbir
Boparai, arguing that while the potential racism involved in the
matter is "despicable," the less obvious scandal is that the
government threw away a staff member with a degree in economics,
the kind of expertise his department desperately
needed.
On Friday, readers are diving into the
story. Weeks later, they are still pondering the questions it
raises - questions about the benefits of the land claim's
requirement for 85 per cent Inuit representation in government,
or the government's policy of decentralization, which has meant
uprooting several departments to small communities. Jimi Onalik
believes the scoop about "the guy from Pang" could have
implications for the GN for years to come.
Bell
has devoted a quarter-century to covering Nunavut and he still
relishes a groundbreaking story. But the work alone did not keep
Bell in the North. He says simply, "I like it here." Though
Iqaluit is often described as a run-down and dirty town, even in
the November cold it is no stretch to imagine becoming addicted
to everything around it: rolling, snow-covered tundra, tufts of
smoky clouds, a bay that changes colour in the blink of an eye as
it freezes over for winter. And for some there is an inescapable
pull in the pain of the place, something that might resonate with
a person's own sense of melancholy. Bell accepts this
proposition, sighing deeply. "I've always thought it's
important," he says, "to be aware that, in a sense, all life is
essentially tragic."
The shift from more
defeats to more victories, unlike the icing of the bay, is
neither certain nor quick. Bell has made the transition
gradually. Perhaps, in its time, Nunavut will too. For that,
possibly more than anyone, Bell can't wait.