After going through five day-care providers in
18 months, Sue Pigg was at her wit's end. Pigg worked full-time
as an editorial writer at The Toronto Star
while her first child, Shannon, was a baby. She was horrified to
find out that her babysitter's husband was using drugs. At
another babysitter's home, Pigg's husband, Tim, found Shannon
already bundled in her snowsuit at the front door when he came to
pick her up-he had no idea how long she'd been waiting. And at a
third, there were so many children that Shannon began acting out
her stress by biting other kids.
With her second child,
Graeme, Pigg decided she couldn't maintain her frenetic pace any
longer. In 1991 she began working part-time as a copy editor,
then moved to the assignment desk. Though it wasn't a position
she had ever aspired to, it allowed her to spend a lot more time
with her children. Now, with a third child, two-year-old Claire,
Pigg isn't sure when she'll go back to working full-time. Today,
as a part-time assignment editor at the Star,
she works three nights, an average of about 25 hours a week. Pigg
would like to be the city editor and has been approached about
management positions, but she just isn't willing to put in the
hours required to move up the newsroom ladder. Right now her
career plans are on hold, but working part-time is "a way to keep
my hands in daily journalism," she says. "That was really
important to me, to not get completely off track. I wanted to
find a way to basically hang on by my fingernails."
A
framed picture of Shannon as a baby sits on a cabinet in Pigg's
dining room. She's in a high chair, holding The Toronto
Star, with an amused look on her face. Shannon, now 9
and home from school for lunch with her friend Ashley, is
laughing so hard she falls off her chair. They giggle, planning a
sleepover Ashley is having for her birthday party this weekend.
Claire, in fuzzy, red Elmo slippers, runs from dining room to
kitchen to living room and back, throwing a few somersaults on
the way. A basket of toys, play table and stack of games sit in
the corner. On the wall in a hallway is a mounted, colourful
finger painting of tulips and sky, labelled "Shannon, aged 5."
Underneath it is a "Happy Mother's Day" poem covered in
handprints, entitled "Graeme, aged 3." Pigg tells Claire to sit
and eat and asks Shannon if she remembered to return her library
books. During lunch, Tim calls and Pigg recounts how Claire
locked her in the bathroom by accident this morning. Shannon
disappears downstairs and returns wearing a promotional T-shirt
designed by the Star: a head shot of Pigg with
the headline-"Her 18 hours of persistence gave you new insight
into trial." Pigg says when she and her friends began starting
families, they were still really ambitious, wanting to go after
great stories, work late and travel. "We all went into this
thinking you could have it all. It wasn't even something we
questioned," she says. "Then we had kids and realized this is
really hard."
The Globe and Mail's
arts reporter Val Ross, now on leave on a Southam Fellowship,
remembers a day about five years ago that she spent working on a
complicated Ontario Arts Council budget-cut story. The story was
due by 5:30 p.m. to run in the next morning's paper. At four
o'clock, she checked her phone messages. There was one from her
son, who was 10 at the time. "Hi, Mom! It's me," he said. "I
forgot to tell you you're in charge of costumes for the school
play tomorrow. On your way home from work tonight would you pick
up four god costumes." God costumes? What did that mean-Greek
gods? A thunderbird? An arty, symbolic representation? "Oh God,"
she thought. In the end, she turned their old karate outfits
inside out so they were all white, fashioning silver headbands
out of aluminum foil. Pretty lame, she says, but not bad for such
short notice. "When you're trying to get an article done and your
kid is sick or trying to get a project into school the next day,
the laundry needs doing and people have head lice or measles, you
don't know where to begin," Ross says.
The newsroom of
the '90s is filled with women like Pigg and Ross who face a
difficult juggling act as they try to balance the competing
demands of career and family, ambition and the desire to be there
for their children. As they find ways to cope, they are part of a
slow evolution in the pattern of work-an evolution that
recognizes the realities of modern family life.
Robert
Glossop, the director of programs and research for the Vanier
Institute of the Family, says the structure of the workforce has
been built on an old model of the family. "The nature of the
contribution made by men back in the '50s and '60s to the labour
market was made possible by virtue of the fact that there was a
woman at home taking care of the kids and taking care of his
needs as well," Glossop says. "Employers could, in a sense,
assume that there was this invisible resource to them, which
basically subsidized the productivity of their own employees."
Journalists are part of a changing work force, one that
has seen a dramatic influx of women over the past 30 years,
especially those with young children. In the early 1960s, 30 per
cent of women were in the paid labour force; by the early '90s,
that number had doubled. Today, almost 70 per cent of women with
young children work outside the home-partly because families
require two incomes to match what they were earning in 1980.
Dual-income families have become the cultural and
statistical norm. The workforce relies on women at all stages in
their lives, and although men are becoming more involved in
domestic life, women still spend one to two hours more each day
than men on activities like housework, shopping and child care.
The result of this "double shift" is stress. A 1992 StatsCan
survey found that almost 30 per cent of women working full-time
in dual-earner families felt they were severely time-crunched,
always trying to accomplish more than they could handle.
A 1994 report on women in the economy by the Canadian
Labour Market and Productivity Centre argues that the changing
nature of the workforce "calls for parallel changes in our social
infrastructure. The lack of adequate social supports for working
families has major implications for the labour market of today
and for the future." Levi Strauss & Co. realized those
implications when it examined work place issues in 1991. A
company task force found that lost work time-due to absenteeism,
lower productivity and workforce turnover-was often a result of
the conflict between work and family. "In this global economy,
the key competitive variable is now the quality of the
workforce-its skills, knowledge, creativity and motivation," says
Julie White, a public affairs manager at Levi Strauss. "A company
that ignores employees' needs to balance their work and family
lives may be making a costly mistake."
Understanding
the link between supporting workers with young children and
corporate performance has led to the growth of family-friendly
policies at Levi Strauss and other companies. These include
flexible working hours, dependent sick leave, generous maternity
and paternity leave and, more rarely, on-site day-care centres,
or at least referral services to qualified care.
The
newspaper industry in Canada has reflected this trend, though it
certainly hasn't led the way. Pigg is the first part-time
assistant city editor and assignment editor the
Star has had. It's a small measure of a more
willing attitude on the part of newspapers across Canada to
accommodate employees. The Star, Canada's
largest independent daily, has formal polices that allow
employees to job share, reduce their workweek and to fund a leave
of absence by deferring compensation. At the other end of the
spectrum, The Vancouver Sun has only a formal
policy on job sharing, but working fewer days a week has still
become more common.
"If you don't offer good employees
some options," says Shelley Fralic, deputy managing editor of the
Sun, "you risk losing good people." But she
also points out that flexible work arrangements such as
part-time, flextime, job-sharing and compressed or reduced
workweeks don't always work within the context of a newspaper.
It's true that long hours, travel, unpredictable schedules and
daily deadlines are inherent in the 24-hour, seven-day-a-week
nature of the news business, because stories don't always break
in convenient nine-to-five working hours. This makes it difficult
to apply blanket policies.
Even Canada's largest
newspaper conglomerate, Hollinger-owned Southam, has no national
corporate human resources policy; it leaves those decisions to
managers at each of its 32 daily newspapers. The Ottawa
Citizen, for example, has a work program that allows
employees to reduce their workweeks and receive prorated
benefits. The arrangement is renewed yearly and can be continued
indefinitely, with two weeks' written notice by either party to
end the agreement, and employees' full-time positions are held
open for them. Job-sharing is also an option. For most of the
past 10 years, Keri Sweetman, an assistant entertainment editor
at the Citizen, has shared positions, working
three days a week. Sweetman, who has three children, who are 7,
10 and 14, moved to editing because as a reporter "there's no
predicting what time you'll finish work. You might have to go out
on a story at four o'clock in the afternoon."
Susan
Riley, a columnist at the Citizen, says when
she had her first child in the early '80s, "you were kind of
expected to keep on working as if nothing had happened. That was
certainly the expectation I put on myself." Riley later
job-shared as an editorial writer, then tried working a four-day
week. She believes women who choose to withdraw from the career
ladder while their children are young shouldn't be seen as
uncommitted or uninterested in being good journalists-that
attitude "leaves the way open for mediocre men."
Don
Butler, the Citizen's executive news editor,
says the barriers holding women back in the newsroom are fading
fast. "If you want to get the most talented people into key jobs,
you're going to have to accommodate the fact that, periodically,
some of them are going to go off and have babies," he says. "I
think newspaper management is on the right page on that." The
Citizen hired Lynn McAuley as sports editor
when she was seven months pregnant with her second child and held
the position open for her until she returned from her four-month
maternity leave.
Sheila Pratt, managing editor of
The Edmonton Journal and mother of a
three-year-old, says family-friendly policies are key to keeping
women journalists in the workforce. "Especially with populations
in the newsroom getting older," Pratt says, there need to be
"workplace policies that are flexible enough to allow women to be
moms and have time with their kids as well as pursue their
journalism."
The Journal is one of
only two Southam newspapers in Canada with an on-site day-care
centre (the other is the Calgary Herald.)
Journal employees are also able to take up to
three days each year to care for a sick child or relative. Paula
Simons, a cultural issues writer at the
Journal, says the paper's progressive attitude
was one of the reasons she decided to move back to Edmonton,
where she's from, after working as a producer on CBC Radio's
The Arts Tonight in Toronto. Simons has just
returned to work after being on maternity leave for 13 months.
The Journal, like the Star
and the Globe, allows employees up to a year
off for maternity leave, although it doesn't supplement EI
benefits. The Citizen and the
Herald, on the other hand, offer the minimum
leave, but do "top up" EI earnings to 95 per cent. Simons now
works three days a week, covering essentially the same beat she
had before her leave. She says she's thankful to have an employer
that sees the wisdom in allowing her to work fewer days. "For
those three days they get my absolute focused attention," she
says. "I'm not crying at my desk."
Jenny Lee, a
business reporter and columnist at The Vancouver
Sun, says trying to find a balance between family and
work is an issue that "seems to really tear at your guts and your
heart in the early years." When she wanted to reduce her workweek
after her first child was born nine years ago, it wasn't common
in her newsroom. She and several other women drew up a formal
proposal and management agreed to try flexible work arrangements.
Lee now works three days a week, from 7 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., so she
can pick up her two children from school. She says her kids have
had a big impact on her career advancement. "It's velocity. I'm
not going at 120 miles per hour-I'm down to idle," she says. "But
that's my choice."
Thomson Newspapers, the
third-largest newspaper owner in Canada with nine daily and nine
weekly newspapers, also has no national policy on human resource
issues. Thomson's flagship paper, The Globe and
Mail, has a casual approach to flexible work
arrangements, but Sylvia Stead, the Globe's
deputy managing editor, says she can't think of any staff who
have been turned down when they've asked to reduce their working
hours. Stead has two children, and she worked part-time for five
years while they were young. She says she made it clear when she
went on to more senior jobs that her kids came first. "I'm not
going to work what has been the tradition in this business, the
12-hour day," she says. "Period. I'm not going to do it."
The attitude of an employer makes a big difference in
how people perceive conflict between their work and family roles.
The Globe's education reporter, Virginia Galt,
has four kids. She remembers one morning she played hooky from
work because her son Alex was in Toronto's city cross-country
finals. She went to watch the race and as she cheered, she turned
to see Colin MacKenzie, the Globe's managing
editor, standing behind her. His daughters were in the race and
he was playing hooky too.
Before she was married, Galt
wanted to be a foreign correspondent. But the globe-trotting life
of a correspondent-for many the pinnacle of a newspaper
career-is, for the most part, still out of reach for those with
children. Kathleen Kenna, Washington bureau chief for the
Star, is on the road about two weeks out of
four. It requires "an incredible amount of energy and a
willingness to leap on and off planes," she says. Kenna decided
not to have children early in life, in part because of her desire
to be a foreign correspondent. To be a great mother, she says, "I
would have to make some other career choice."
Jan
Wong's kids, Ben, 7, and Sam, 4, were both born while she was
The Globe and Mail's foreign correspondent in
Beijing. Wong says although people here may wonder how she did
it, she herself actually wonders how people here do it. In
Beijing, Wong had a cook, a housekeeper, a nanny and a driver,
and for the latter part of their stay her husband quit his job
and was also home. When they returned to Canada, Wong says they
were doing laundry at two in the morning before they found a
nanny.
As women take on more responsibility in the
world of work, men are taking on more responsibility in the
home-but it's still rare for men to make a significant change in
their work lives to accommodate child rearing. Last year, Martin
Mittelstaedt, who was the Globe's Queen's Park
bureau chief, took an eight-month leave of absence after his
wife, Margaret Philp, a social policy reporter at the
Globe, returned to work following her second
maternity leave. The Globe allows fathers six
months of unpaid leave, plus vacation time. Philp says it was
amazing how much more she could accomplish at work with
Mittelstaedt at home with the kids. If a story broke late, she
could cover it without worrying about the "day-care dash."
It's middle of January, and now that her husband is
back at work, things have changed. Today, Philp didn't file a
story, so she's picking up the kids. If she had a deadline, he
would pick them up. So far they've been lucky; there hasn't been
a day yet since Mittelstaedt returned in the new year that
they've both had to stay late to cover a breaking story. Philp
leaves the Globe at 10 minutes after five,
uncommonly early for her newsroom, walking quickly and checking
her watch every so often. Early in her career, Philp was
nominated for a National Newspaper Award. She loves her job and
knows she's good at it, but she also realizes she's not reaching
her full potential there right now because she has kids. "It's
frustrating. If you could just stay late you know you could break
the back of a story you're working on," Philp says. "But never is
there any question of what comes first."
It's a short
streetcar ride to Queen's Quay and she's just in time to catch
the 5:30 ferry boat to Ward's Island, where she and Mittelstaedt
live. The ferry crossing takes about 10 minutes. Toronto's
skyline-skyscrapers rising into fog as dusk settles
downward-recedes into the distance, as the small, friendly lights
on the island come closer. Two little bundled figures with rosy
cheeks are waiting for Philp on the other side: Philp's
babysitters have brought Christian, almost 4, and Hannah, almost
2, to the ferry dock to meet her. Philp trundles Christian and
Hannah on a red, plastic sled to the small, toy-scattered house
they're renting while their house is being renovated not far
away. Hannah is tired, wet and hungry. Philp nurses her while
Christian watches Kratt's Creatures on TVO,
then starts dinner. She stops the pasta from boiling over as
Hannah wheels a toy stroller around the tiny kitchen and
Christian plays with a shiny red fire truck that has a loud
siren. Philp settles Hannah in her high chair with a bowl of
noodles, most of which end up on the floor.
Philp says
she's often tired and thinks about working part-time, although
she did try a four-day week after Christian was born and didn't
feel as productive as she wanted to be. Finding the right balance
is different for everybody; there are no magic solutions to
maintaining both a satisfying career and a fulfilling family
life. "It's hard," Philp acknowledges. "It entails sacrifice to
your career and it still affects women more than men. But I
wouldn't trade places with anyone."
It's an often
precarious, sometimes messy, choreography of racing against the
clock to finish a story or frantic phone calls when child-care
arrangements come tumbling apart, leaving parents scrambling. But
the newspaper industry is evolving as it becomes more attuned to
the needs of families. There are choices now that weren't as
readily available 10 years ago, choices that acknowledge the
different roles people play. It seems that newspapers have
finally realized what parents have always known: that kids are as
important as the next big story.